Sam Hudson’s side twice fought back after falling behind against a talented Category 1 team which reached the final last season, losing to Manchester City.
Eventually the Blues were undone in the 102nd minute of extra-time as the visitors secured a 3-2 win – and here are our player ratings...
5. Ciaran Martin - 7
The left-back who has been on loan at Moneyfields was given a tough evening by impressive right-winger Vincent. However, he really grew into the game and it was his shot in stoppage-time which resulted in May's leveller. Photo: Jason Brown
6. Reggie Buckland - 7
(Replaced by Max Hammond on 87 mins) Very neat and tidy in the centre of midfield. Didn’t stop chasing and pressurising and used the ball well. Photo: Jason Brown
7. Luke Staight - 8
A commanding presence in the centre of midfield. Worked hard, puts in a tackle, and has a good range of passing. Photo: Jason Brown
8. Jermaine Osifo - 6
(Replaced on 46 mins by Nathaniel Chioma) Collected the first booking of the game on 24 minutes and was given a final warning by the referee after his enthusiasm saw him commit another foul not long later. Thankfully he calmed down for the remainder of the first half, but was substituted at half-time. Photo: Jason Brown