Leadership problems at NHS South Central Ambulance Service with concerns over ‘workforce culture’
The Care Quality Commission says some improvements have been made to the trust’s leadership, but there is still a long road ahead
Ambulance service staff are experiencing “workforce culture” problems which is affecting morale - with the trust’s leadership being scrutinised by the Care Quality Commission (CQC).
The regulatory body determined that the leadership of South Central Ambulance Service (SCAS), which covers Hampshire and elsewhere, requires improvements. Despite taking positive steps forward over the past two years, a significant number of frontline workers and other staff lack belief in upper management.
The report published following an inspection in January said “workforce culture and staff experience remained a concern”. Amanda Williams, CQC deputy director of hospitals, secondary and specialist care in the south east, said the trust established a more stable leadership team which strengthened overall management - acting upon previous feedback - but more still needs to be done.
“The trust had been discharged from NHS England’s recovery support programmes,” she added, “however, these improvements were still at an early stage and inspectors weren’t assured the systems leaders had in place were robust enough yet to consistently identify risks or to drive sustainable improvements for people using services.
“We also found the trust’s focus on finance and performance had impacted on staff culture, which had taken a back seat while other improvements were made. The 2024 NHS staff survey showed areas such as staff wellbeing and morale had deteriorated and staff continued to report burnout and concerns about staffing levels.”
The grade for SCAS has risen from inadequate to requirements improvement. Citing the 2024 survey, Ms Williams said it was concerning that only 50 per cent of frontline staff felt safe to speak up, and 68 per cent didn’t believe their concerns would be addressed.
“We know if staff don’t feel able to report concerns it can lead to risks going unaddressed and people receiving unsafe care, so it’s vital leaders take these findings seriously,” she added.
The SCAS Annual Report for 2024/2025 announced major changes to put the organisation on a more stable financial footing. CEO David Eltringham said the trust faced “significant financial and operational challenges”, but changes allowed for a forecasted surplus of £4.6m for the year instead of a planned deficit of £10.1m.
“This surplus includes £6m of deficit funding and £7.5m in brokerage funding. In the year the trust has also gone through a corporate restructure, which has had an impact on staff and operations,” he added.
The SCAS Annual Report and Accounts for 2025/2026 outlined a £1.4m surplus, which “reflected three years of continuous financial improvement from a £36m deficit position”. It added that the timeframe had seen “a period of transformation in the trust”, as it continued to “balance performance and financial sustainability through our modernisation programme, building an ambulance service fit for the future”.
One of the major changes has been the number of staff employed in Patient Transport Services. This workforce takes people to hospital outpatient clinics and other appointments if they can’t access them due to health conditions. This includes being admitted to or discharged from hospital wards, and being brought to medical facilities for life-saving treatment such as radiotherapy, chemotherapy, renal dialysis and other treatments.
Contracts covering SCAS Patient Transport Services in the Thames Valley and Sussex areas were lost and passed onto the private sector. Numbers in that workforce have dropped from 743 to 292. Overall staff levels fell from 4655 in March 31, 2025, to 4187 12 months later. Emergency 999 frontline staff saw a small increase from 2292 to 2303.
The CQC found the trust “hadn't addressed weaknesses in leadership at some levels, and this was putting delivery of safe, effective care at risk”. It added that not enough has been done to tackle inequalities in recruitment processes, with ethnic minorities and disabled applicants not being as successful in recruitment compared to their white counterparts.
Ms Williams’ assessment wasn’t entirely negative though. Leaders did ensure the focus remained on people’s safety, with individual safety stories being shared at board level and staff having huddles to review incidents and agree immediate improvements. The trust was also proactive in making sure people and their families had a say on how services were designed and delivered.
Ms Williams said: “We did see examples of good practice, including improvements in cyber security, good partnerships with other services in the community and a strong focus on learning and innovation. For example, the trust was exploring the use of AI (artificial intelligence) to improve safety for people contacting its emergency operations centres.
“It was clear leaders understood what still needs to be done to embed improvements and make them filter through to the everyday experiences of staff and people using services. We will continue to monitor their progress and return to check that changes have been made.”
SCAS is continually aiming to improve care while managing financial pressures. Interim managing director Stuart Rees said: “The CQC has recognised many positive developments, including stronger leadership, excellent partnership working, innovation, research, wellbeing support, and the dedication of frontline staff.
“At the same time, the report challenges us to build on these foundations by further strengthening culture, speaking up, inclusion, leadership, and governance.”
Chief nurse Helen Young said CQC’s message is that meaningful progress has been made, but more work is needed to convert this momentum into lasting change. “The task now is to ensure colleagues across the organisation increasingly see and feel the benefits of those improvements in their day-to-day working lives, and that translates into helping us all deliver the best possible care to all our patients.
“Delivering safe care to our patients remains our top priority, even through challenging times of performance and the need to be as efficient as possible. We also must not underestimate the effort that has gone into frontline service improvements, resulting in our updated service reports published earlier this year.”
.jpg?width=96&crop=1:1,smart)