'Gutted, heartbroken, deflated': Fans react as Portsmouth suffer penalty shoot-out defeat to Oxford in League One play-off

PORTSMOUTH’s play-off run came to an end as they lost to Oxford United in a penalty shoot-out at the Kassam Stadium.

The Blues and The Us could not be separated over two legs and extra time.

Cameron McGeehan is challenged by Matty Taylor of Oxford Unitedplaceholder image
Cameron McGeehan is challenged by Matty Taylor of Oxford United

However Oxford triumphed 5-4 on penalties on Monday evening.

The defeat means that Pompey are facing another season in League One.

placeholder image
Read More
Oxford United vs Portsmouth: 18 photos as Blues lose on penalties in League One ...

Here is how fans reacted:

@Joe121099 said: ‘I will always be Pompey, born and raised as a Pompey boy. Through all the highs and all the monumental lows. Every time I’ve said “we go again” but not like this. Change needs to happen, and happen ASAP. Should’ve walked the league with the squad we have, yet here we are. Again.’

Freddie Webb wrote: ‘Hate being cynical about Pompey, but they threw it away. They weren't outplayed, makes it worse, did I miss anything?’

Jake Smith said: ‘Well. That's the season done for #Pompey. Gutted. Heartbroken. Deflated.’

Liam Gant wrote: ‘Well that was awful.’

@Marrcus23 said: ‘That was beyond awful. Won’t have a better chance to get to the Championship for years.’

Tim Benfield wrote: ‘Pompey know how to ruin your summer!’

Mark Hawkins said: ‘Pompey in the play-offs ain’t meant to be.’

Sean Rawlings wrote: ‘Yet another year in League 1. Big overhaul needed.’

News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice