Historic pub in Southsea recommended for housing redevelopment

Plans to convert the former Carter and Co into housing have been recommended for approval, despite concerns raised by residents over the loss of pubs.

Portsmouth City Council’s planning committee will consider proposals to turn the former pub at 30–34 Great Southsea Street into four homes.

The scheme would see the Grade II listed pub and adjoining former fishmongers, most recently used as a pub and bed and breakfast, split into two large dwellings.

Two additional three-storey houses would be built on the beer garden, completing a gap in the terrace.

Planning officers have recommended the scheme for approval, concluding that it would deliver much-needed housing in a sustainable location while preserving the character of the conservation area.

In total, eight public representations were received, including six objections. Critics argued the loss of the pub would be “a major blow to the local community”, with one stating: “Far too many pubs are closing.”

Concerns were also raised about parking pressures, the potential for the homes to become short-term lets, and the impact of a proposed roof terrace on neighbouring privacy.

However, supporters said the building had struggled in recent years and welcomed its reuse. One comment noted it was “better for it to be used for any purpose than languish empty”.

The applicant said a noise abatement notice had restricted the pub’s trade, contributing to its eventual closure.

Council officers concluded that, while pubs are valued community assets, there are several alternatives nearby, such as the Hole in the Wall and The Barley Mow.

They also found the design acceptable, stating the homes would “make a positive contribution to the streetscene and Conservation Area”.

Subject to a legal agreement to mitigate environmental impacts, the scheme is recommended for conditional approval.

In March this year, the owners of Carter and Co announced the closure of the pub since it opened in May 2021.

The building was originally constructed as the India Arms pub in 1902 and later became “The Tiffin Room”, then “The Italian Bar and Grill” before becoming Carter and Co.