Sonia Exelby was ‘scared’ and in ‘so much pain’ before being stabbed to death by ‘executioner’, court hears

The jury are set to consider their verdicts

A Southsea woman who allegedly flew to America to be murdered confided in a friend she was “scared” and in “so much pain” before her death, a court heard.

“Executioner” Dwain Hall, 54, is accused of stabbing Sonia Exelby to death after she was found by US investigators in Marion County, Florida, on October 17 last year.

Dwain Hall smiling in the dock on the final day of the trialplaceholder image
Dwain Hall smiling in the dock on the final day of the trial | Court TV/Youtube

“Predator” Hall, who is on trial in Florida for first-degree murder and kidnapping, had demanded Sonia, 32, pay 4,000 dollars (£3,000) for him to kill her when she travelled to the US last October after meeting Hall on a fetish website, the trial previously heard.

Sonia’s body was discovered buried in a shallow grave near a highway, in the same area where the defendant lived, with just a bra and sandals on and her dress “laid on top of her”, jurors had heard.

The trial at Marion County Judicial Centre heard of Sonia’s suffering during the final hours of her life. On October 11, Sonia messaged Ari Petursson, a friend, via the social media website Discord to say that she was being held captive at gunpoint in a cabin.

Sonia Exelbyplaceholder image
Sonia Exelby

Sonia told her friend: “No one will find me in time.”

She went on: “I’m sorry he keeps taking my phone…he doesn’t trust me with it.

“He made it clear there was no way out unless I shoot him. I was questioning it last night. I can’t kill anyone. He always has it on him…There’s wifi but it’s s***.

“He’s watching me every time he gives it back except now I gained some trust.”

Sonia concluded the messaging by saying she was “so, so scared”, in “so much pain” and that her “time is up”.

Prosecutor Amy Berndt told jurors of messages exchanged between Hall and Sonia on festish site Motherless months before her death.

Dwain Hall’s trial is taking place at Marion County Judicial Centreplaceholder image
Dwain Hall’s trial is taking place at Marion County Judicial Centre | Court TV/Youtube

Sonia, who went by the username AlreadyYours, told Hall, who went by the name Alpha Sadist, told Hall in one message on April 5, 2025: “I got worried about you, I’m lost without my alpha sadist.”

Another said: “Like so happy my cheeks ache from grinning. I’ve missed my alpha more than I could imagine…Absence does make the heart grow fonder. I can’t be without you.”

Prosecutors have accused Hall of preying on Ms Exelby’s fragile mental health for his own gratification and relishing in his role as her “executioner”.

Meanwhile, the court heard defence lawyer Junior Barrett questioning Dr Jason Demerey, a neuropsychologist. The defence lawyer told the court Sonia was “upset about how long it was taking her to die” when she was at the cabin with Hall, who was seen smiling and laughing with his legal team during the final day of the trial.

Dr Demerey, who reviewed messages sent by Sonia when she was allegedly being held captive while being tormented, said: “She said it’s (dying) taking longer than she otherwise thought.”

Mr Barrett replied: “Is her dying not what was intended?” Dr Demerey responded: “I think that’s a fair position to take yes.”

However, Dr Demerey said it was not necessarily the case she intended to die in America. “Her ambivalence far outweighs evidence of a clear plan in my opinion,” he said.

He added: “It’s possible that her mental and emotional state fuelled in part by her physical abuse she had experienced could have made it seem as though it was taking a lot longer than she expected.”

Dwain Hall’s trial is taking place at Marion County Judicial Centreplaceholder image
Dwain Hall’s trial is taking place at Marion County Judicial Centre | Court TV/Youtube

The court previously heard that evidence linking Hall to Sonia’s death includes a shovel with her blood on it, mobile phone data and a knife recovered from a friend of the defendant.

The judge is now giving his legal directions to the jury before they retire to consider their verdicts on Hall.

(Proceeding)

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1877
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice