In a bid to answer that question we took to Facebook and asked our readers – and hundreds of them had their say.
We’ve counted up their responses to bring you their definitive top 22 Christmas films of all time.
MORE HERE: 30 stunning photos of our readers' Christmas trees and decorations – which is your favourite?
This hefty breakdown is in descending order, so page one will show the movies they ranked 22 to 19.
Keep on reading to see what tops the list.
Do you agree with their choices?
A message from the Editor, Mark Waldron
You can subscribe here for unlimited access to Portsmouth news online - as well as fewer adverts, access to our digital edition and mobile app.
For Black Friday we’ve slashed the cost of a new subscription by 30 per cent - so you can get unlimited access to our coverage for as little as £1.40 a month.
17. Santa Claus the Movie (1985)
This film, rated U, was 6th on our readers' list. Photo: Tristar Pictures
18. The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992)
Into the top 5 now and this film, rated U, was 5th on our readers' list. Photo: Walt Disney Pictures
19. Home Alone (1990)
This film, rated PG, was 4th on our readers' list. Photo: 20th Century Fox
20. Elf (2003)
Top 3 alert! This film, rated PG, was 3rd on our readers' list - with 53 votes. Photo: New Line Cinema
5 / 6